The decision in one question

Is a cheaper legacy airframe worth the older systems and tighter performance, or do you want the current-production trainer?

The table below uses the same versioned PlaneFit dataset as the Finder. Prices and operating costs are planning estimates, not quotations.

Decision factorPiper PA-28-140 CherokeeView aircraft profileCessna 172S Skyhawk SPView aircraft profileMooney M20C RangerView aircraft profile
Typical market year196720191967
Estimated purchase€55k€497k€105k
Annual cash cost at 80 h€72k€32k€80k
Five-year cash outlay€417k€655k€506k
Cruise speed105 kt124 kt140 kt
Advertised range500 nm640 nm900 nm
Seats444
Realistic payload343 kg301 kg338 kg
Runway need520 m497 m500 m
Data confidenceNormalized for direct comparisonNormalized for direct comparisonPreliminary, verify source data before deciding
Main trade-offAffordable and forgiving, but performance is modest and many aircraft now need substantial refurbishment.Exceptionally easy to support and resell, but four adults with bags and meaningful fuel are usually unrealistic.Excellent efficiency at a low purchase price, but fuel tanks, gear and decades of modifications require specialist inspection.

Where each aircraft wins

A factual first pass. Mission, condition and configuration can outweigh a brochure advantage.

Lower indicative purchase pricePiper PA-28-140 Cherokee
Lower estimated annual costCessna 172S Skyhawk SP
Faster cruiseCessna 172S Skyhawk SP
Longer advertised rangeCessna 172S Skyhawk SP
More realistic payloadPiper PA-28-140 Cherokee
Shorter take-off requirementCessna 172S Skyhawk SP

Choose Piper PA-28-140 Cherokee when...

Four-seat light trainer and local tourer. Its central ownership trade-off is: Affordable and forgiving, but performance is modest and many aircraft now need substantial refurbishment.

Planning snapshot: €55k indicative price and €72k annual cash cost at 80 hours.

Read the full aircraft profile →

Choose Cessna 172S Skyhawk SP when...

Four-seat training and personal touring aircraft. Its central ownership trade-off is: Exceptionally easy to support and resell, but four adults with bags and meaningful fuel are usually unrealistic.

Planning snapshot: €497k indicative price and €32k annual cash cost at 80 hours.

Read the full aircraft profile →
Your mission, not a generic winner

Test both aircraft against your airports, passengers and annual budget

Open Aircraft Finder